Ice Cream Lovers Should Run, Not Walk, To Try Costco's New Cookie Monster Ice Cream Bars

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

If you’re a frequent Costco shopper (get a membership here), you might be making a huge mistake. It’s easy to get into a routine, hitting the same spots in the store every time, thinking that you’re gaming the system by sticking to your list and staying focused. Well, think again. If you’re shopping logically, responsibly, and maturely at Costco, then you’re probably missing out on some of their best products. So if you haven’t visited the freezer aisle full of sweet treats in awhile, you need to add it to your list, because Costco just started selling a pack of Cookie Monster ice cream bars that you won’t want your freezer to be without.

https://www.instagram.com/p/CxpI4u3rwk8/

A post shared by Shannon (@costco.so.obsessed)

What the heck is a Cookie Monster ice cream bar? Luckily, no furry puppets were harmed in the making of these frozen ice cream bars, which are made by Afters Ice Cream. The company is known for its gourmet flavors, and Cookie Monster is no exception. Each bar features a blue Madagascar vanilla ice cream that’s loaded with chocolate chip cookies, crushed Oreo cookies, and chocolate fudge. The ice cream is then dipped in chocolate, and the bars are frozen.

A post shared by Afters Ice Cream (@aftersicecream)

Costco is currently selling Afters Cookie Monster ice cream bars in 10 packs, which cost $14.99 in store. That’s a lot less than what you’d pay for at an ice cream shop. And what’s more, the reviews rolling in on these sweet treats are pretty positive across the board. “Finally found them,” shared one excited shopper. “They’re way better than I expected!!!”

What if you don’t live near a Costco? It turns out that you can buy 4-packs of Afters Ice Cream Pints on Goldbelly. It’s a bit of a splurge, but the flavors sound honestly to-die-for. We’re talking Dark Matter brownie batter ice cream loaded with fudge chunks and chocolate swirls, Salty Oreo cookies and cream ice cream, Trippy Tea Party Ice featuring jasmine milk tea and mochi boba, and more. You can choose the four flavors you want to include in the pack, and yes, they have Cookie Monster so you can satisfy the new craving you never knew you had, even if there’s no Costco nearby.

It may be fall, and you may have a Costco membership mostly to save on bulk-sized pack of paper towels, but let yourself loosen up a bit. Celebrate autumn the most whimsical way you can: eating blue ice cream loaded with cookies as you watch the leaves fall outside.

Satisfy your sweet tooth with more awesome Costco bakery items seen in the gallery below.